Advisor-bar

Apple pulls anti-gay app after online petition receives 146,000 signatures

Posted March 23, 2011 1:01pm by Phil Hornshaw Tags: Exodus International, Apple, App store

Within just a few days of the story spreading across the country and the Internet and an online petition garnering more than 146,000 virtual signatures, Apple (AAPL) has removed the Exodus International app from its iTunes App Store.

The free app, by the Exodus International ministry and bearing the same name, included video, podcasts, news updates and blogs that carried Exodus’ message of “providing support for individuals who want to recover from homosexuality.” That message had quite a few people pretty upset.

We told you about this story on Monday, when outraged gay rights groups and activists were calling for the app’s removal and questioning how Apple had approved it in the first place. The Exodus app boasted that during Apple’s app approval process, it had received a 4, a designation which states that the app includes “no questionable content.”

Obviously, there were at least 146,000 people who didn’t agree with that assessment.

Apple, unsurprisingly, isn’t commenting on the matter, but Exodus International is gone from the App Store today. According to a story from Mashable, members of Truth Wins Out, the activist group pushing for the app’s removal, applauded the move.

“Apple made a wise and responsible decision to dump an offensive app that demonized gay and lesbian people,” said Wayne Besen, executive director of Truth Wins Out.

Meanwhile, members of Exodus International claimed they were the victims of propaganda and the Exodus International app’s purpose and message had been confused or misinterpreted.

“I want to provide the information and education for people who are looking for an alternative to unwanted same sex attractions,” said Jeff Buchanan of Exodus International in a story in the Baltimore Sun.

This isn’t the first time Apple has reversed itself and pulled an app that was offensive to gay people. A similar situation happened last year, although it had a much smaller petition of only 7,000. And Apple has a pretty pro-gay track record: it gave money and support in California to fight Proposition 2, an initiative that added an anti-gay marriage clause to the California constitution.

The removal of Exodus International’s app begs a question that many would consider to be pretty serious: what is going on here? Does Apple agree with such apps and stances as that of Exodus International, or does it block things like it that many people would find offensive? Is this approval and the last one an oversight? One wonders just how stringent the App Store approval process actually is if an app, that is pretty clearly offensive to a large group of people, could make it through and be left available on iTunes for more than a month.

More than a few people are wondering where Apple stands and what its review process is like in light of apps like Exodus International getting through to the App Store. It seems as if Apple itself might want to make those policies clearer and decide where it stands on issues, as well as what kind of apps it wants in its store before it gets slapped with petitions.

Musings

Missing

First off--no company in their right mind will EVER tell you the truth on which stance they take. Apple is a business--it will always do what's politically correct and doesn't hurt their business. Second--what do you care if they are pro or con on the gay/lesbian/bi issue? I'm sure the app's are made every day and no one has time to check everyone of them to determine what's offensive to you or them. They do not put their name on it, the developer does and then in turn pays Apple to get to the app store. Again--business is business. If the developer feels that it is not offensive to them, and the rest of the world does--that's their perogative. We all are entitled to our own opinions.

Associated Apps:  Exodus

Reply to comment Posted March 23, 2011

imjustsayn

Missing

How utterly ridiculous it is that apple should have to waist their time censoring their app store for the beliefs of a handful of ignorant people. And what kind of precedent does this set? By this reasoning they would have to pull all Bible apps? Otherwise they are profiting for the sale of literature that claims that god himself believes that gay men must be put to death. Here's one of many taste quotes you will find in these ever-tolorent apps:

Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13 - Holiness Codes - "You shall not lie with a male as one lies with a female; it is an abomination" and "If there is a man who lies with a male as those who lie with a woman, both of them have committed a detestable act; they shall surely be put to death. Their bloodguiltness is upon them"

I always find it amazing how the bible and other "holly" documents and opinions always get a pass for everything from intolerance and hate-speak to homosexuality to pedophilia.

-imjustsayn

Reply to comment Posted March 23, 2011

thepianoman

Freddie_phoenix

Let me point out to you that not everything in the Bible is set in stone. There are other passages that would tell you it's wrong to wear fabric blends, work on Sundays, or play football. I need more than "the Bible says so" for something to be wrong in my moral compass. http://www.stumbleupon.com/su/17jowj/pics.blameitonthevoices.com/062010/homosexuality_is_a_sin.jpg

And excuse me- did you really just say "a handful of ignorant people"?! Do you think it's cool to ridicule our kind like that? We didn't choose to be this way. We chose to accept that God made us this way.

Reply to comment Posted March 23, 2011

openminded

Missing

the bible also says you have to sacrifice goats. Have you ever done that?

Reply to comment Posted March 23, 2011

imjustsayn

Missing

I'm truly sorry that you missed my meaning. Your observation of the other nonsensical quotes in the bible is my point exactly. Taking any of it seriously is a joke and a waste of time. The bible, the app and these posts.
Btw. I have many gay friends and the godfather to my only son is gay, so again you have misjudged my coments. I love them all because they're great people and far to confident and sure of their lives and sexuality to waste a moment of their lives giving any of this homophobic crap energy. Screw the app, screw the bible and get on with this amazing life.

Posted March 23, 2011

ewilliams

Missing

Hey Phil - quick correction for you: California's Prop 2 was a successful ballot initiative to prevent animal cruelty. The anti-gay marriage initiative you mentioned in your post was actually Prop 8, not Prop 2.

Reply to comment Posted March 24, 2011
Facebook Activity