Advisor-bar

Here are the new rules for picking a cell phone carrier

Posted July 20, 2012 11:01am by Brad Spirrison Tags: Smartphones, AT&T, Sprint, Cell Phone Plans, carriers, verizon, t-mobile, coverage

Apps mentioned:

There are more variables than ever to consider when signing-up for cell phone service.

New shared plans offered by AT&T and Verizon are changing the economics of how individuals and families access voice, data and texting services. Additionally, as 4G phones become commonplace, understanding which carriers offer reliable 4G connections becomes all the more critical.

Before signing-up for a new cell phone plan for you or your family, chew over these five new rules for picking a cell phone carrier.

1) Determine whether a shared plan will save money for you and your family

Next month, AT&T is scheduled to debut its Mobile Share plan for new and existing subscribers. This follows Verizon’s Share Everything plan, which was introduced last month. Both plans offer unlimited voice and texting services for a fixed fee, and charge extra based on the number of devices included and how much overall data is consumed. While the pricing and services for each plan are generally similar, the biggest distinction is that AT&T gives its subscribers the option to choose between Mobile Share and other existing plans. New Verizon subscribers, however, have no other choice but to sign-up for Share Everything.

So how can you determine whether a shared plan is cost-effective versus individual plan options? Consumer Reports advises AT&T subscribers with “low or moderate” data needs to stick with individual plans as this point. Individuals with one smartphone connected to the Mobile Share share plan are charged $95/month plus taxes and penalties for 1GB of data. Overage fees thereafter are $15 for each GB. In comparison, individual voice and data plans on AT&T range between $59/month (450 minutes and 300MB of data) to $99/month (unlimited voice/texting and 3GB of data).

So the benefits of shared plans from both AT&T and Verizon only come into effect as you connect more devices (smartphones, feature phones, tablets, connected laptops) to your plan. Both AT&T and Verizon offer attractive packages that connect two smartphones with two feature phones and 4GB of data for $210. From there, the packages get more cost-effective as you add more devices and data to them.

While Sprint and T-Mobile also provide opt-in shared and family plans, their packages have not changed as dramatically in recent months. However, if AT&T and Verizon are successful with their new offerings, expect the two other major carriers to follow suit.

2) Monitor your data consumption – but don’t pay for more than you need

One additional and unfortunate wrinkle in Verizon’s Share Everything plan is that existing subscribers who enjoy grandfathered unlimited data plans will not be able to upgrade their phones at subsidized prices. That means that new and shiny smartphone you want to buy for $199 will actually run you more than $500. For most of us, that negates the benefits of having an unlimited data plan. Verizon is not the only carrier getting stingier with its data. Earlier this year, AT&T confirmed that subscribers still on their unlimited plans (no longer available to new customers) could see data speeds slow down after 3GB are consumed in a billing cycle. T-Mobile’s “Classic Unlimited Plan” for $95/month reduces high speed data after 5GB are consumed in a billing cycle. At this point, Sprint is the only remaining major U.S carrier to offer unlimited data plans.

But is not having access to unlimited data really the end of the world? According to Nielsen, the average smartphone owner consumes less than 500MB of data each month. So if you are a relatively light data user who likes to email, browse the web and maybe play the occasional game or two, you can save $10 to $50 per month or more on AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile with plans that offer 1GB of data. Paying for unlimited data, or as much as 5GB of data per month, is best for family plans or individuals who constantly play games and/or watch videos on their smartphones without wireless Internet connections.

3) Research coverage maps for the best 4G networks in your area

As we increasingly treat our cell phones like handheld computers, the speed and reliability of the networks they are carried on become more important than ever. If you are about to purchase a new phone and things like high-speed Internet connections, video conferencing and HD gaming are important to you, than you should research which carrier in your area offers the best 4G connection. While AT&T is lauded by PCWorld and others as having the fastest 4G download speeds, the other carriers got a head start in offering nationwide 4G coverage. Before choosing a provider, check out the coverage maps offered online by Verizon, AT&T, Sprint and T-Mobile, as well as other regional providers you can access. You don’t want to shell out the big bucks for a state-of-the-art phone and two-year plan, and not have access to the fastest network possible.

4) Be mindful of your privacy before downloading certain applications

Advances in mobile media technology offer great benefits like the ability to identify nearby retail sales or happy hours in our area, as well as what our friends and contacts might be doing at any particular time. Of course, the counter-effect is that we sacrifice elements of our privacy to make these things possible. While many of us are proactive about deciding what personal information we are willing to give up for these services and conveniences, many third-party applications are not always forthright about what they are doing with our information.

Earlier this year, it was discovered that many popular apps like Path, Twitter and Yelp were uploading iPhone users’ address books to its servers without explicit permission. There is no evidence that the companies were doing anything nefarious with that information, and the offending app developers immediately revised their practices once they were revealed. Still, in this era where the technology is moving so quickly and so many new services are available at our fingertips, there is a good chance some of the information on our phones is stored by unknown third parties. Proceed with caution, and research the background and user and professional reviews of unknown applications before downloading them.

5) Consider a prepaid plan

While prepaid cell phone plans that don’t require two-year commitments have long been available, their biggest drawback was that they didn’t typically offer higher-end devices. This is no longer the case. Last month, prepaid plans for the iPhone debuted for the Cricket and Virgin Mobile USA networks. Those carriers and others are also beginning to offer among the best Android and Windows devices. There are still various pros and cons you should consider before investing in a prepaid plan. But if you resisted in the past because of poor handset selections, now is a great time to consider prepaid options.

Download the Appolicious Android app

ecadvocate

Missing

Check what actual users of each carrier experience on a block by block basis from phone tests uploaded to public maps www.rootmetrics.com www.sensorly.com and www.opensignalmaps.com

All three apps work on Android, iOS not so much.

Run tests wherever you go with your smartphone and contribute to the map so the carriers can't say they didn't know.

Verizon is NOT the best. What people think is the worst is NOT the worst. It depends on the city and who's tower got there first.

Reply to comment Posted July 23, 2012

Pavla

Missing

That is so true. I had Verizon and on a trip to Los Angeles (you know that tiny hick town in California), in downtown (you know a very unpopular place), inside a meeting room at the Sheraton Hotel (a tiny mom and pop venue) I got absolutely NO coverage (NOTHING) my battery drained in 3 hours. I had to borrow a phone from my coworker (which did NOT have Verizon) attending the same conference so I could all my boss to tell her that my phone was just a paperweight while I was attending the conference. This happen several times during the year. Once my commitment ended (the exact last day of the contract) I switched. Is the service better, on my home town is the same, traveling it is a tiny bit better. The MONTHLY price is A LOT BETTER.

Reply to comment Posted November 13, 2012

tech

Missing

it's better to try the unlocked Android smartphones that work with any carrier, contract free (work with prepaid sim card); these 3.5'' smartphones with dual core cpu, 3G, only $99 on KooBay

Reply to comment Posted July 23, 2012

Pavla

Missing

Unfortunately that is next to impossible to get in the USA since the phones are either GSM (ATT, T-Mobile) or CDMA (Verizon, Sprint). So you are just getting 50% of the carriers one way or the other. An to make matters worst there are so many 3G and 4G networks between them that it turns out that your "unlocked" phone is really locked to one carrier (the one they inetended the phone to work with).

Reply to comment Posted November 13, 2012

chicagoguy1

Missing

What I would like to see before I sign my next 2 year contract is two things – 1) make the cell phone companies hold to a performance contract meaning no dropped calls and fading signals. Dropping more than 10 calls a month should get a 15% refund and if more than 30 calls a month the right to drop them as a carrier without penalty. 2) When ones contract is up and you are given credit towards a new phone with a new 2 year contract the discounted price of that phone should be greater for renewing customers than a new customer. Example a Galaxy S III 4G is $199.99 for renewing existing customers and $39.99 for a new customer. It doesn’t sound cell companies want to keep their customers. It’s especially sad that in the rush to sell IPhone and make a large profit they didn’t at the time worry about customer data usage or try to update the bandwidth. Now they are just looking to charge extra for data.

Reply to comment Posted July 23, 2012

ESCO_NY

Missing

1st- a cell phone is a radio transmission(a wireless connection) you will never have a cell phone company have no dropped calls. if you dont want dropped calls, i would suggest to get a landline. 2nd people are buying iphones like crazy, they are in a rush to sell them because they are making money, which is what a business is suppose to do in order to stay in business. charge extra? i remember when unlimited calling back in the day was 199.99 no txt or data included. the only thing that i might agree on is that renewing customers should get a little extra perk for staying. ex. waiver of upgrade fee and or even an extra 50 bucks off or something.

Reply to comment Posted July 24, 2012

No_one_in_Particular

Missing

I am afraid, the data-measurement software does not distinguish between the transfer of already-paid-for advertisement and the subscriber's own data. This results in a penalty on subscribers that do not choose unlimited-data plans. Has any-one-else felt this regressive scenario?

Reply to comment Posted July 24, 2012

zuko33

Missing

Why do so many people keep saying that new Verizon subscribers have to sign up for the share everything plan. If you actually go to the Verizon site and go through the process of signing up as a new subscriber you are given the choice of the share everything plan or the same plans that they have always had.

Reply to comment Posted July 24, 2012

mityblumpkin

Missing

that is correct. its the know it alls with the lack of research that screw up america.

Reply to comment Posted July 24, 2012

IthXero

Missing

Starting tomorrow, July 28th, the rest of the plans are supposed to disappear so it's not actually incorrect.

The share everything plans for 99% of people with more than one phone are less money monthly so having the choice for a LOT of people is going to be moot.

However for users like myself who only have one line, there are no savings and I have to give up my unlimited(though rarely used) data plan to get a good price on a new phone when my contract is up.

Reply to comment Posted July 27, 2012
View All Comments »
Facebook Activity