Advisor-bar

Why we’re all better off without a Verizon iPhone

Posted September 27, 2010 7:03am by Kevin Maney Tags: Apple, Blackberry, Google, verizon

Be glad that Verizon Wireless (VZ) isn’t getting the iPhone anytime soon – it’s the best thing that could happen for all of us.

Of course, it may not seem like the best thing for you, individually. You probably want the best smart phone (arguably Apple’s iPhone) on the best U.S. network (Verizon’s) – not the best smart phone on a so-so network or a so-so smart phone on the best network.

On postings all over the Web, you can read the groans over Verizon CEO Ivan Seidenberg’s admission last week that nothing is in the works to bring the iPhone to Verizon in the foreseeable future. iPhone users are stuck with AT&T (T).

And yet, this is for the collective good. If Verizon had gotten the iPhone much earlier, the entire smart phone milieu would not be as vibrant as it is. If Verizon gets the iPhone now, the market won’t be all it could be.

New networks of innovation

Let’s start with the phones. Because Verizon and Sprint (S) have been shut out of the iPhone, they’ve had to look for alternatives to keep its most demanding, highest-revenue customers from migrating over to AT&T. That gave breathing room to phones based on Google’s Android, allowing them to flourish as Verizon and Sprint drove phone makers to please come up with something to counter the iPhone.

[Related: Big rival catching up to the iPhone]

Android phones are now pretty darn good. By August, Android had grabbed 27% of recent smart phone subscribers, according to Nielsen – pushing Android ahead of iPhone in U.S. market share. Indeed, Seidenberg last week put it this way: “We don’t feel we have an iPhone deficit.”

That in turn has forced Apple to be better. Not that Apple’s bad about improving products – it continues to make iPods better even though there’s almost no real competition in that space. Still, Apple (AAPL) has driven iPhone development hard, improving speed, memory, software, reception – all while driving the price aggressively downward.

Why? Because the iPhone has real competition. Android may not have the buzz of the iPhone – but an Android on Verizon is, for many people, a match for iPhone on AT&T.

Smartphone competition is good for everbody

All in all, the competition has driven Apple, Google (GOOG) and the various Android handset makers (Motorola, HTC, etc.) to innovate. The situation has pushed RIM’s Blackberry and H-P’s Palm to improve quickly or risk being driven out of the market. Subtract the competition, and that innovation would become less of an imperative. A survey by Credit Suisse found that up to 8 million Verizon subscribers would jump to the iPhone if it were available on Verizon – enough to damage the emerging Android ecosystem and dampen the competition.

The battle for customers has made the networks better, too. By exclusively offering the iPhone, AT&T has forced Verizon and Sprint to invest in their networks to keep customers, and in fact both are close to rolling out 4G networks, ahead of AT&T. Now, AT&T has to race to keep up on 4G.

Think of the situation in reverse: If the iPhone had been available all along on AT&T and Verizon and even Sprint. The iPhone would’ve swamped all other smart phones and Verizon would’ve felt less of a threat from AT&T. The tension and competition in the market would’ve been less, and consumers would’ve been the losers, with fewer handset choices, fewer features on the best phones, and networks improving at a slower pace.

Eventually, the iPhone will no doubt wind up on Verizon. But, hopefully not for another year or so. Let the competitive market do a little more work to make the phones and networks better. We’ll all benefit.

Other popular Yahoo! stories:

Natalie Portman called Facebook movie's 'secret weapon'

New teammate punks Shaq with a dunk

Explained: Unusual origin of the 'peace' sign

LWJewell

Missing

You make an excellent argument in your article. If the iPhone was available on all the networks there would be less competition, and less innovation.

I love my iPhone, but long for the ability to switch to Verizon or Sprint or whichever network is offering the best features and price.

Reply to comment Posted September 27, 2010

Sup12

Missing

I think this is stupid of what verizon is doing. Obviously, iPhones and att is way better than others especially metro
i have iPhone 4 and i love it
my bro had droid hate it

Reply to comment Posted September 28, 2010

yancybox

Missing

Your comments may be true; however, I can say this. I have been a Sprint customer for the last seven years, and worked for AT&T for five of those seven years. While working for AT&T I had an employee phone which was a BlackBerry until the iPhone came out. During these times I have had BlackBerry's and Andriod phones on my personal Sprint account. When accessing websites on both phones at the same time my Sprint phones ALWAYS opened the sites first. Both Verizon and Sprint operate on the CDMA network while AT&T is on GSM. It is no secret CDMA is much faster than GSM. I would have never had the AT&T phone due to the Internet speeds had it not been required for my position.

All phones have issues when they are first released. AT&T received thousands of complaints and returns on the first generation iPhone, just as Verizon and Sprint did with Andriod. I currently have the new HTC 4G Evo and love it. Over 20 of my friend who 'where' iPhone user have now switched to Sprint to get the HTC because they liked it much more then their iPhone. I was even able to cancel my home Internet service because I am able to connect up to 8 devices with my phone; therefore, there was no reason to pay for cable Internet at home when I could power my laptop with my phone. Not to mention the HDMI port which allows me to download movies and then connect the phones directly to the TV and watch them.

So, what Verizon and Sprint are doing and have done is far from stupid, it's genius! They don't need the iPhone when they have phones that are better, do more, save you money and move with speeds that leave AT&T in the dust. And now with Sprints 4G network, it's even faster, can't wait until they get it in my area, it will be epic.

Posted September 28, 2010

Malent

Missing

trust me when i say that Verizon is much better off without the Iphone. The Iphone really isnt that good of a phone technically speaking, i think that Droids are alot more stable when it comes to technical issues. i have extensive first hand knowledge of troubleshooting these things on a daily basis and all i can say is good call Verizon. The worst part about AT&T having the Iphone really is the fact that they are so expensive and they no longer offer an unlimited internet package anymore 2GB max and anyone who lives off their phone like i do can expect overages.

Posted September 29, 2010

EddieS

Missing

Sorry to disagree slightly with you there, Sup 12. Agreed that iPhone is arguable the best smartphone out there, but AT&T is no where near the best network. Verizon has continiously beaten them in practically all aspects, and Sprint is slowly creeping up to the point of being on par, if not already better than AT&T. This speaking from experiences based on current AT&T customers and previous ones (myself included).

Posted September 29, 2010

jlovanio

Missing

Sup12,

What!?!?

Posted September 29, 2010

abhishekgyl

Missing

and how exactly do you hold your Iphone 4, with a pair of tongs :P

Posted September 29, 2010

geoffkieta

Missing

Is it an iPhone?.......No......Then I don't care.......But is it an iPhone?.......Then I don't care......
Hey look Steve Jobs is jumping off a bridge!!!!! Oh cool, then let's all go jump off a bridge....this is going to be soooooo cool!!!!!

Posted September 29, 2010

saphira

Missing

I very much agree with Sup12... I've never had a problem with apple products where as I've had a problem with every verizon I've owned since 2005.

The droid and iphone are not that different in size, a friend of mine owns the droid X and its almost the size as my netbook!!! O.o

pro iphone for verizon!

Posted September 29, 2010

haris_pilton

Missing

I'm in europe and a virgo smartphone user.
In my country there are 2 select carriers that offer the iPhone. Sure the iPhones nice and if they were almost free with a subscription more people would have them ,but they're not. Now I have a HTC android that is
a) open source thus awesome
b) not a hipster phone
c) open source still awesome

my friend who has an iPhone was in awe when he saw me search and download an mp3 from the net in under a minute and so was I to be honest. (*pow*iTunes*smack*)
Every major app from the app store gets ported and there are 100.000 + apps in the store now.
Hot robot love!

Posted October 10, 2010
View All Comments »
Facebook Activity